The UK government's planned consultation on introducing a captive insurance regime in Spring 2024 is a significant development that could reshape the insurance landscape. For technology experts like us at Root, closely monitoring these regulatory shifts is paramount, as it may open the door for non insurance brands such as supermarkets to leverage captive insurance structures, particularly cell captives, to launch innovative insurance products.

The South African Model: A Blueprint for Transformation

In the early 1990s, South Africa pioneered the concept of the cell captive, allowing entrepreneurs and organisations to enter the insurance market without the need for a full insurance licence. Under this arrangement, a cell captive account is established within a licensed cell captive insurer, and a cell owner purchases special shares to capitalise that cell. 

This unique structure grants the cell owner autonomy in tailoring insurance products, obtaining underwriting, and benefiting from various services provided by the promoter.

In South Africa, this model has empowered non-insurance brands to participate directly in the insurance market, offering them control, flexibility, and innovation at a lower cost compared to a traditional insurance licence. It has proven particularly successful for third-party cells selling insurance to external businesses or individuals.

Seizing the Opportunity for UK Supermarkets

The move towards captive insurance in the UK comes at a crucial time when supermarket giants are already making strides in the insurance sector, reporting consistent growth in areas such as life and pet insurance. With a keen interest in expanding their digital channels, supermarkets are well-positioned to explore embedded insurance and deepen their insurance value proposition.

The competition among leading UK supermarket brands is already fierce and involves various insurance lines, including pet, life, gadget, home, and motor insurance.. The introduction of captive insurance structures provides an additional avenue for supermarkets to differentiate themselves, offering tailored insurance products that align with their brand identity and customer insights. The captive structure would also allow supermarkets to participate more fully in the insurance profits (and losses) of their programmes, creating a healthier alignment of interest than the more typical UK distribution-only model.

Addressing Challenges in the UK Insurance Market

The UK insurance market has faced challenges, with rising rates for 24 consecutive quarters, particularly in property catastrophe, professional liability, and cyber risks according to broker Marsh. Captive insurance solutions present a practical alternative, allowing companies to have control over their policies and reduce costs. However, the current regulatory environment has hindered the growth of captive insurance vehicles in the UK, but the new signals from the regulator give hope to the industry that this may change. .

The anticipated consultation and potential implementation of a captive insurance regime represent a golden opportunity for the London insurance market and the City's financial services sector. The positive outcome could provide a much-needed boost, offering a practical alternative to traditional insurance and fostering innovation within the industry.

Technology as the Enabler

Technology plays an increasingly pivotal role in the successful deployment of scalable captive structures in all jurisdictions, and is particularly relevant for the roll-out of large digitally distributed insurance schemes like those offered by Supermarkets on a variety of personal product lines. Being able to serve customers online across a variety of financial product offerings, including banking and insurance, is now core to the business development strategies of all major UK supermarkets. 

The South African experience demonstrates that a flexible and resilient technology architecture is essential for the smooth functioning of cell captives. As the UK explores these regulatory changes, it is crucial to invest in technology that supports innovation and enables seamless collaboration between cell captive insurers and the non-insurance brands they serve.

Ultimately, the technology platform supporting the captive links the supermarkets and insurer with ease, allowing the insurance proposition to scale with confidence, adapt with market conditions and ultimately unlock the potential of digital insurance offerings as a new revenue stream. 

At the same time, and of utmost importance in the highly competitive world of UK supermarkets, the right technology partner can support the delivery of an exceptional user experience for the insurance offering, further fostering brand loyalty and growth. 

All eyes on the Outcome

As we await the outcome of the consultation, the potential introduction of a captive insurance regime in the UK opens exciting possibilities for supermarkets (and other consumer brands) to become true insurance innovators.

Drawing inspiration from the successful South African model, UK supermarkets can leverage cell captives to gain control, flexibility, and transparency in their insurance offerings, ultimately transforming the way insurance is delivered and experienced by consumers. 

The convergence of regulatory changes, technology advancements, and the innovative spirit of supermarkets may herald a new era in the UK insurance market. Having successfully enabled some of South Africa’s largest supermarkets and cell captive insurers over a number of years, the Root team eagerly anticipates the unfolding developments and stands ready to support the transformative journey of UK supermarkets further into the realm of insurance innovation.

Further Reading: